Sep 30, 2016
Organics coalition opposes certification change to containerized growing facilities

The Crops Subcommittee of the National Organic Standards Board has submitted a recommendation that crops using hydroponic, aquaponic, aeroponic and other containerized growing methods — commonly used for products like living lettuce, herbs, sprouts and leafy greens — should no longer be eligible for organic certification. In addition, the Crops Subcommittee recommended new restrictions on the growing media for producers of other crops that use containers in their farming practices. This would have the greatest impact on the production of organic berries, tomatoes, cucumbers and peppers. The U.S. Department of Agriculture recently published these proposals from the Crops Subcommittee for consideration at the board’s November 2016 meeting.

“The Coalition for Sustainable Organics believes that we should be making it easier, not harder, for people to access organic produce,” said Lee Frankel, executive director for the coalition. “The proposals being presented by a subcommittee of the National Organic Standards Board go against the original principles of organic farming. It was stunning to see their statement that the conservation of natural resources, such as clean water, is not a valid concern for organic production systems.”

Karen Archipley, co-owner of Archi’s Acres, a certified organic greenhouse operation headquartered in Escondido, California, expressed her concerns about the proposal. “The proposal will cause undue harm to our business and discourage farmers and consumers from choosing organics that are truly sustainable,” said Archipley. “The consumers of our living basil, kale, other herbs and produce embrace the fact that we are conserving water and delivering a product of the highest quality and flavor through our production methods, which are truly organic.”

Martin Gramckow, founding member of the coalition for Sustainable Organics and a certified organic grower of blueberries, raspberries and blackberries for Southland Sod Farms in the Oxnard, California area, was also troubled by the recommendation. “While I appreciate the hard work of the members of the National Organic Standards Board, I disagree with the direction taken by the Crops Subcommittee. We need to maintain the sensible current standards for organic production using containers. “Containerized growing allows me to compete against imported produce, and provides a local solution for people in my community. Making arbitrary changes to existing organic rules will increase my costs and make my production less sustainable. These changes are likely to drive me out of business and further limit people’s access to organic produce.”

Container growing is a controlled growing system in which plants derive nutrients from approved organic substances in water and/or growing material. A 2015 study showed water savings of more than 90 percent for container systems versus open-field production systems. These growing methods promote sustainability in many ways:

  • They generally require fewer resources per pound of fruits, vegetable or herbs produced compared to food grown outdoors in the soil
  • In most cases, container growing uses less water, needs less land, significantly reduces soil erosion and extends the growing season of plants
  • It also reduces runoff of nutrients or other chemicals into streams, lakes and water aquifers

USDA has opened a formal comment period where everyone, including consumers, producers, restaurants and supermarkets can express their view on the Crops Subcommittee’s proposal.

“The future of our diverse and sustainable organic supply is at risk,” said Frankel. “People need to share their opinion with the U.S. Department of Agriculture and the National Organics Standards Board to allow our farmers to remain proud members of the organic family.”

Interested parties can express their opinion online by going to and leaving a comment.

Source: Coalition for Sustainable Organics

Tags: ,

Current Issue

VGN April Cover

Tech allows growers to ‘eavesdrop’ on insects

Managing wildlife on the farm

Southwest Florida’s Worden Farm manages challenges

Pennsylvania Vegetable Growers Association says farewell to leader

Southeast Regional Show recognizes leaders

Veg Connections: Biopesticides and beneficial insects

Business: Why do most succession plans fail?

60 years of advocating for agricultural employers

Keeping CSA members engaged and loyal

see all current issue »

Be sure to check out our other specialty agriculture brands

produceprocessingsm Organic Grower